Clinical education

Integrated clinical and academic curricula

Developed by: 
School of Physiotherapy
Institution: 
The University of Sydney
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

In the undergraduate program at the University of Sydney, the Clinical and academic curricula are integrated with students undertaking clinical placements in Year 2, 3, 4. A good example of our integration is the Mentored Clinical placement which is undertaken in first semester of second year. Students attend clinical sites 1 day per week for seven weeks and are required to undertake workbook tasks. The assigned tasks are directly related to 3 academic units of study which are running concurrently in semester 1 of year 2. The three units of study are: Clinical Observation and Measurement, Professional Practice and Evidence Based Physiotherapy. The assessment of these three units of study reflects the integration of the clinical and academic curricula with the workbook tasks providing a component of the assessment in each of the three academic units of study.
The delivery of the academic units of study involve lecture and tutorial format utilising many forms of media including powerpoint, web based materials and digital photos and videos. The clinical components provide a series of practical tasks which need to be completed such as measurement of joint range and muscle strength while others involve observation and structured reflection.

Course Name: 
Bachelor of Applied Science (Physiotherapy), integrated clinical and academic curricula in Clinical observation and Measurement, Evidence Based Physiotherapy and Professional Practice
Year Level: 
Second Year
Expected Outcomes: 

During this clinical placement students will have the opportunity to:
 

  • Apply the theory that you have learnt in the Units of Study: Clinical Observation and Measurement, Evidence Based Practice and Professional Practice.
  • Access information from a variety of sources in the completion of the workbook tasks and in clinical problem solving.
  • Develop skills in collecting, analysing and reporting clinical observations.
  • Begin to develop the written and verbal communication skills needed for clinical work.
  • Develop the ability to work well with other members of a health care team.
  • Observe occupational health and safety guidelines, infection control and emergency procedures in the clinical setting.
  • Discuss the role of the physiotherapist and other health care professionals in the clinical setting.
  • Begin to develop the communication and time management skills required to work as part of a health care team.
  • Develop skills in self evaluation by reflecting upon your performance of the learning tasks described in this manual.
  • Demonstrate professionalism by preparing for this clinical placement as outlined above and adhering to the regulations of the clinical workplace.
Effective Aspects: 

One particularly effective aspect of teaching and learning practice is the linkage between the academic and clinical curricula. Students have the opportunity to apply what they learn in academic units of study directly in a clinical setting. In addition the assessment is integrated with the clinical tasks contributing to the marks for the academic unit both academic and clinical components are valued.

Evaluation: 

The mentored clinical placement is evaluated by surveying students and clinical mentors. In addition clinical mentors undertake a training workshop taught by the Clinical Education team

Evaluation Outcomes: 

The workbook tasks were trialed in 2004 as part of a 4 week Yr 2 placement and were well received by students and educators. However the general consensus was the number of tasks was too high to be completed in the 7 day timeframe. Therefore, modification of the workbook tasks was undertaken in response to the student and educator feedback. The Mentored Clinical placement in its integrated academic and clinical form ran for the first time in 2005. Analysis of formal evaluations of students and mentors is underway.
Feedback from the Clinical Mentor training workshop was extremely positive.

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

The formal evaluation of the placement by clinical mentors and students will be reviewed and modification made where necessary. .
 
 
The workbook tasks will change as the material presented in the academic components is modified and updated to be consistent with the latest developments and evidence in physiotherapy.

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Dr Catherine Dean
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Physiotherapy
Contact Institution: 
The University of Sydney

Community Health Placement (learning about wellness) in clinical practicums

Developed by: 
School of Physiotherapy
Institution: 
The University of Sydney
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

The Community Health Practicum is a 5 week practicum in which the student explores areas of health need that have not been traditionally covered in physiotherapy programs, such as mental health, aged care, health promotion, sports coverage, obesity prevention and management. These areas reflect the changing health care needs of the Australian population and will ensure that graduates are well positioned to provide appropriate care in the changing health climate. For example, one community health practicum might involve 3 days per week in a nursing home and weekends covering weekend sports, such as school football or local netball teams.
This practicum offers less formal structure and greater diversity than traditional practicums and this will enable students to gain the generic skills of flexibility, time management and adapting to changing health care needs.
 
Students are required to generate independent learning contracts specific to the practicum. These learning contracts are developed and negotiated with practicum mentors. Students and practicum mentors work collaboratively to develop strategies to ensure attainment of the learning contract. In addition to assessment of physiotherapy clinical skills, students are required to reflect on the diversity of the practicum and provide evidence of the learning process.

Course Name: 
Bachelor Physiotherapy
Year Level: 
Third Year
Expected Outcomes: 

The students will be required to satisfy the unit of study learning outcomes that include physiotherapy specific objectives and generic objectives related to development of learning contract

  • Assesses the patients' abilities, problems and needs
  • Interprets and analyses assessment findings for the diagnosis of the patients' problems and the definition of patients' needs
  • Develops a physiotherapy intervention plan to meet defined goals
  • Implements physiotherapy intervention involving - manual skills and therapeutic equipment
  • Implements physiotherapy intervention involving - training and teaching
  • Evaluates the effectiveness of physiotherapy intervention and modifies accordingly
  • Communicates effectively and appropriately
  • Demonstrates professional behaviour appropriate to physiotherapy
  • Operates effectively within the healthcare system
  • Ensures safety of patient, staff and self at all times
  • Develop a learning contract relevant to the placement that is mutually negotiated with the clinical mentor.
  • Outline the strategies and resources that will help meet these learning needs.
  • Identify potential evidence of successful completion of learning objectives.
  • Critically review the process and outcomes of the learning contract.
Effective Aspects: 
  • provision of health care to match the community needs in a variety of settings
  • development of an independent learning contract
  • taking responsibility for attainment of the learning contract, including time management, communication with mentor.
  • Collection and presentation of evidence of reflection on learning process.
Evaluation: 

The community health practicum in the current program runs as Community Fieldwork. This unit of study has been evaluated by the three different stakeholders involved in the operation of the unit. The stakeholders include the students, the academic advisors and the fieldwork mentors. Students were asked to complete the university's Unit of Study Evaluation (U.S.E) form. The remaining stakeholders were asked to complete a survey specifically designed for evaluation of the unit.

Evaluation Outcomes: 

Students - initially students reported difficulty drawing up their own learning objectives and undertaking completion of the objectives. However, the vast majority of students reported that once they were on placement they enjoyed the opportunity to work in their chosen area and learned a great deal from the placement and the experience.
Academic Advisors - Most academic advisors were positive about the unit of study.
 
Fieldwork Mentors - The vast majority of mentors indicated that they were highly satisfied with the objectives and implementation of the unit; the students' professionalism and performance; and the opportunity to assist student's learning in non-traditional health/community settings.

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

This is the last year that Community Fieldwork will be offered because the undergraduate curriculum is changing. Most aspects of the Community Fieldwork placement will be incorporated into the Community Health practicum, which is offered for the first time in 2006.

The placement will be extended from 2006, and it will more specifically target health care needs of Australians, and the contribution that physiotherapy can make.
 

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
K. Refshauge
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Physiotherapy
Contact Institution: 
The University of Sydney

Clinical practice workbooks

Developed by: 
Pauline Chiarelli
Institution: 
The University of Newcastle
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

As a part of initial introductory clinical placements in years 1 and 2, students complete Clinical Practice Workbooks. The workbooks are designed to enhance the clinical experience by encouraging student to seek out, perform and document specific structured tasks, and to reflect on their performance. Workbook activities require students to relate the clinical impairments documented in assessment tasks to the patients' quality of life assessed through discussions with patients. In addition, the workbooks encourage students to learn about the physiotherapist's work environment through tasks that require reflection on management and safety issues, manual handling, and equipment use. Clinical reasoning is enhanced through tasks that require the student to discuss observations from patient charts or interviews that are necessary for clinical decision-making. Students present a patient case to their peers following their first placement, and presentations are guided by their clinical workbook activities.

Course Name: 
The clinical practice workbooks are used in years 1 and 2 as part of the learning process for the students' clinical placements. The initial clinical placements are half-day placements that introduce the students to the clinical environment. Students attend a clinical site for one afternoon a week for 7 weeks. Students attend two clinical sites in year 1 (semester 2), and two sites in year 2 (semester 1) for 7 weeks each. Clinical workbooks are tailored to each year, with specific questions and reflective activities that represent the competencies that students should be focused on for each unit. Clinical workbooks in year 1 are part of Physiotherapy II, which focuses on basic treatment skills. Clinical workbooks in year 2 are part of Physiotherapy III, where the focus is on electrophysical agents.
Year Level: 
First Year
Expected Outcomes: 

Year Level : (First and Second)
 
The clinical workbooks are intended to enhance learning from the clinical placement experience, by requiring the student to document and reflect on their experiences. For example, in year 1 the students learn about the physiotherapist's work environment through workbook items encourage students to seek out induction information such as clinic management, safety and manual handling policies. Year 1 students are also required to reflect on the impact that physical deficits have on a patient's quality of life after they have performed one or more measurements on a patient (ROM, strength and balance), and interviewed them about aspects of activities of daily living. In year 2 students begin to explore clinical reasoning, documentation and outcome measures used in the clinical setting by describing and reflecting on patients whom they have observed or treated. They are also required to describe aspects of safety with electrophysical agents and exercise equipment, including patient explanations, warnings and consent. It is expected that these activities enhance the clinical placement experience by providing the student with specific goals to be achieved and allowing the student to reflect on how effective they were at achieving those goals.
 

Effective Aspects: 

The opportunity that students have to reflect on their own progress, shortcomings and strengths, and the process of comparing their learning experiences at different clinical site makes this activity an effective self-directed learning process.

Evaluation: 

Marking the clinical workbooks gives teaching staff a better picture of the student's insight into the clinical experience, and of the students' ability to transfer learning tasks to the practical setting. Reflective tasks indicate whether the students are able to express how their actions and observations affect patient outcomes and level of care. Formal evaluation of the students' perceptions about the usefulness of completing the workbooks has not yet been undertaken.

Evaluation Outcomes: 

There has much variation in the quality and quantity of responses to the reflective tasks, but the majority of students appear to put quite a lot of time into their clinical workbooks.

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

Yes. We would like to further structure some of the workbook tasks, to encourage students to spend more time on reflective tasks, and less time on other tasks.
 
A change to the distribution and submission of completed workbooks is currently being trialed. An internet version of the workbooks has been developed, so that students can submit their workbooks online. The online version allows for only limited text for some activities, and for other activities students are allowed to expand their responses as they wish.

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Suzanne Snodgrass
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Health Sciences
Contact Institution: 
The University of Newcastle

Clinical school model to facilitate clinical education for all students

Developed by: 
Joan McMeeken, Gillian Webb, Cathy Nall collaboratively with many academics and clinicians
Institution: 
The University of Melbourne
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

Physiotherapy students are allocated to one of the three general Clinical Schools of the Faculty on entry into year one of the physiotherapy course. Each Clinical School has an Associate Clinical Dean of Physiotherapy who is responsible for approximately 120 or one third of the undergraduate students. With the exception of 12 weeks of elective units and eight weeks in paediatric and gerontological physiotherapy all students spend their clinical education periods in their own Clinical Schools. This provides students with a university clinical base. Here they are well known by clinical and administrative staff, are supported by the infrastructure of the Clinical School and are familiar with the site environments and their requirements. In the Clinical School each student spends the equivalent of a week in each of the first two years, 18 weeks in year three and 12 weeks in year four.
An overview of the content and management of the clinical education components of the course is the responsibility of the Clinical Education Committee. The whole course is developed in conjunction with the clinicians who participate in discipline specific working groups. Course outcome, assessment, content and supporting teaching materials such as problem based learning triggers, manuals and multimedia are planned, developed and completed in these groups. The academic program is integrated within the clinical education program with appropriate teaching sessions occurring at the clinical sites. The clinicians have responsibility for continuous clinical assessment and the discipline specific and final clinical exams. Assessment reliability is established within the working groups.
The Associate Clinical Deans, with the support of their staff, the School of Physiotherapy's Clinical Coordinator and the undergraduate administrative team manage the clinical program. Junior clinical staff have management and content responsibility for the clinical education program in years one and two. They also act as mentors for students in years three and four. Senior clinicians oversee the clinical education program in these latter years.
An Associate Clinical Dean of Physiotherapy is a member of the School's Planning and Resources Committee and participates in senior academic staff selection. The Head of School participates in selection of Associate Clinical Deans. Clinical staff with significant educational responsibility are Fellows of the School of Physiotherapy and have full access to all University resources. In addition the University School of Physiotherapy runs general and site-specific inservice programs related to clinical education and in the specialist discipline areas. Clinical staff from the Clinical School teach elements of the academic program within the University.
The contained nature of the distribution of the students within the Clinical Schools enables the program's support by the International Student Support Program of the Faculty. As well as dedicated computers, telephone, fax and email the clinical education program is supported by 'Plexus' - an electronic data source for student timetables, assessment forms, information on clinical sites and clinical staff. It also includes notes on supervision and experiential learning for the clinicians.

Course Name: 
Throughout the four years of the undergraduate BPhysio and BPhysio (Hons) courses
Year Level: 
First Year
Expected Outcomes: 

Year Level : (First to Fourth)
 
The key learning outcome is that BPhysio and BPhysio (Hons) graduates fulfill all the expectations of their employers as new graduates and demonstrate the attributes of University of Melbourne graduates and all the ACOPRA competencies of physiotherapy graduates.
 

Effective Aspects: 

There are advantages in the integrated academic and clinical education program from the perspective of academic staff, clinicians and students.
Academic staff

  • Respect for clinical physiotherapists and strong sense of collegiality with clinicians
  • Development of strong linkages with Clinical School staff, knowledge of their expertise and co development of assessment and teaching materials
  • Co development of research activities and recruitment of graduate students and co supervision of graduate students
  • Assuredness of student placements in a strongly supportive and academically and clinically strong environment

Clinicians

  • Respect for academic physiotherapists and strong sense of collegiality with academics
  • Development of strong linkages with academic staff, knowledge of their expertise and access for inservice and collaborative activities
  • Co development of research activities and co supervision of graduate students, support for research activities
  • Established pattern of clinical placements
  • Development of strong professional relationships with students
  • Potential to recruit future employees for the Clinical School

Students

  • Development of professional identity and collegial support within own Clinical School
  • Secure clinical environment where the individual students learning needs are known
  • Limited number of geographic sites and familiarity with the various requirements of these sites
  • Potential for future employment with the Clinical School
Evaluation: 

The Clinical Education Committee and the discipline specific working parties are part of the dynamic continuous curriculum review. An example of changes that are introduced quickly as a result of legislative requirement was the integration of the "no lift" policy formally into the clinical curriculum.
Members of the Clinical Schools participate in all School strategic and operational planning processes
Students provide feedback on all clinical subjects and this information is provided to the clinicians involved. This process was originally paper based, but now occurs electronically through 'Plexus".
There is an annual anonymous questionnaire evaluation of employers' perception of the graduates and detailed discussion of graduates' outcomes with members of the physiotherapy profession who employ graduates.
Evaluation of graduates through the National Course Experience Questionnaire, through university surveys and through the annual School survey and informal feedback is integrated into the School's review processes.

Evaluation Outcomes: 

All questionnaire and survey results and discussions with graduates and members of the physiotherapy profession indicate strong support for the integrated academic and clinical program through the Clinical School Model. The close collaborative relationship continues to enable academics and clinicians to respond in a timely and considered fashion to issues arising in either environment.

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

This is a dynamic program such that annual cycles of evaluation result in changes to the processes and curriculum as appropriate.

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Joan McMeeken
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Physiotherapy
Contact Institution: 
The University of Melbourne

Integrated Clinical and Academic Learning

Developed by: 
Libby Gass, Norman Morris and Megan Dalton
Institution: 
Griffith University
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

Clinical Units are integrated into an academic course (subject) throughout the physiotherapy program. Prior to and following each clinical placement students discuss their clinical experiences with the supervisor of clinical education, the course convenor (following clinical unit) and a psychologist (following clinical unit).

Course Name: 
Clinical Units are embedded in academic courses. Students need to satisfactorily complete both the academic and the clinical components of the course.
Year Level: 
First Year
Expected Outcomes: 

Year Level : (Clinical units are undertaken across all semesters of the 2 year graduate entry Master of Physiotherapy Program and in the final 3 years of 5 year Bachelor of Physiotherapy/Bachelor of Exercise Science Program.)
 
Prior to undertaking clinical placements, students complete coursework relevant to the upcoming clinical placement. Typically, students complete a viva/practical exam prior to undertaking the clinical placement. Moreover students meet with the Clinical Education Coordinator to discuss the expected experiential learning outcomes of the clinical placement. The expected outcomes of this teaching and learning practice are a better overall preparation and 'theoretical' preparation of the student for clinical placement.
 
At the completion of the clinical placement block (either one four-week or one eight-week block) students meet again for a debriefing session. Students are able to comment about similarities /differences of individual clinical experiences and discuss and relevant issues that may have arisen during the clinical placement thereby creating a shared learning environment.

Effective Aspects: 

n/a

Evaluation: 

Surveys of clinical educators.
 

Evaluation Outcomes: 

Qualitative and quantitative analysis suggests that clinical educators are happy with level of preparation of the students for clinical practice.

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

No changes are expected.

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Norm Morris
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Physiotherapy and Exercise Science
Contact Institution: 
Griffith University

Additional development assessment form used to enhance physiotherapy student feedback and clinical performance

Developed by: 
Sue Jones and Kerry Saunders
Institution: 
Curtin University of Technology
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

Final year students in the School of Physiotherapy at Curtin University of Technology spend most of their year in clinical placements and are required to demonstrate that they meet the Australian professional competencies. Students receive both formative and summative feedback throughout the placement. Students who do not meet the competencies fail. A handful of students may meet most of the competencies, but have areas of weakness (usually in generic attributes) which are likely to impact on their performance in subsequent placements.
An Additional Development Form is completed by the Clinical educators for these students who then meet with the Clinical Program Coordinator to discuss the issues impacting on their performance. A management plan is designed to support their development of deficient competencies. Support may range from accessing specific counseling by the University services, provision of additional teaching support, strategies to overcome learning difficulties, accessing appropriate mentoring, reviewing lifestyle factors or identifying cross-cultural barriers to communication and performance.
 
A detailed plan of action outlining the issues, strategies used and additional suggestions to support learning are provided for both the student and the supervisors in the student's next clinical placement. Discussions with all parties ensure that students and supervisors are working together to assist the student to develop the required professional behaviours and competencies. Additional monitoring of student performance and supervisor support occurs during subsequent placements to ensure both parties' needs are met.
Provision of support facilitates students who are expected to take responsibility for their personal and professional development, and ensures that these students receive the appropriate assistance to achieve successful completion of the program.
 

Course Name: 
The clinical units in the final year of the Bachelor of Science and Master of Physiotherapy (Graduate Entry) programs
Year Level: 
Third Year
Expected Outcomes: 

(Final year of the programs)
 
Students will be able to critically evaluate their own performance in clinical practice.
Students will be able to develop professionally and personally, with appropriate assistance, as determined by the plan of action they develop.

Effective Aspects: 

Students must take responsibility for their own learning and for their personal and professional development, working together with clinical teachers.

This additional development form is used to identify issues that affect student's clinical performance that may otherwise not be suitably assessed in formal assessment procedures.
 

Evaluation: 

Formally through the Clinical Education Committee and Curriculum committees.

Evaluation Outcomes: 

Very positive feedback has been received from clinicians, academics, employers and the students themselves.
 

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

n/a

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Sue Jones
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Physiotherapy