Complex cases

Physiotherapy care of patients with end stage disease

Developed by: 
Rosemary Isles (Neurology) and Cath Johnston (CP)
Institution: 
The University of Newcastle
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

Students attend a tutorial session related to the issues surrounding caring for patients with end stage disease in adults and children. This is a joint session between Cardiopulmonary and Neurological Physiotherapy courses. The focus is mainly on end stage neuromuscular and/or respiratory disease.
Physiotherapists are frequently confronted with these situations and students are generally unprepared when it comes to dealing clinically with the complexities of managing the patient with end stage / terminal disease. It was determined that a tutorial session examining the role of the physiotherapist, clinical decision making and the emotional aspects of end stage disease was necessary.
 
Students are provided in advance with short case studies of patients with end stage neurological, neuromuscular and respiratory disease. These are case studies in which the tutors have been personally involved. Questions are provided for each case study which direct the students toward exploring and reflecting on:

  • The effects of end stage disease on body systems and function
  • The role of the physiotherapist in treating patients with end stage disease
  • Clinical decision making and clinical reasoning in treatment planning for those with end stage disease
  • The effects on the patient and family of terminal / end stage disease
  • Their own emotional response and concerns related to caring for such patients.
     

The tutorial session activities include general discussion and identification of the student's issues and concerns related to the physiotherapy management of patients with terminal / end stage disease. Times when students have actually come into contact with end stage patients are identified.
 
The case studies are presented and discussed. Specific physiotherapeutic management clinical reasoning, treatment plans and techniques for the patients concerned are explored. Time is then spent discussing the effect of terminal / end stage disease on the patient's family, carers and involved health care workers. Students are encouraged to reflect on their own emotional response and concerns. Practical strategies for dealing with the emotional aspects of treating patients with terminal / end stage disease are identified and discussed.

Course Name: 
Combined practical / tutorial session - Cardiopulmonary Physiotherapy II (PHTY3020) and Neurological Physiotherapy II (PHTY3010)
Year Level: 
Third Year
Expected Outcomes: 

Year Level : (Third Year Semester 1)
 
Students will:

  • Understand the progression of certain terminal neurological (neuromuscular) and respiratory diseases and the effect of these diseases on function in adults and children.
  • Understand the specific medical management of these patients at end stage.
  • Understand the role of the physiotherapist in the management of patients with end stage disease (particularly neuromuscular disease) and how physiotherapists may provide palliative care at this time.
  • Understand the issues of terminal / end stage disease for the patient and their carers.
  • Explore and be aware of their own emotions, feelings and expectations related to caring for those with terminal / end stage disease.
  • Identify practical strategies for dealing with the emotional aspects of treating patients with terminal / end stage disease

 

Effective Aspects: 

This session proved to be effective for the students in facing, exploring and understanding the issues surrounding care of the patient with end stage or terminal disease.
The case studies used for the session were those in which the tutors had personally been involved. Tutors were able to share their firsthand experiences with the students in a frank and relevant manner. Many of the students had faced some of these issues on their previous clinical units or in their own lives.
 
This session effectively integrated teaching across courses (CP and Neuro) giving students the chance to discuss the physiotherapy management of complex patients with multiple problems.
 
The students were able to discuss the actual physiotherapeutic management of end stage patients and explore what physiotherapists can offer in terms of supportive and palliative care. They were also able to share and discuss in their own feelings and concerns related to caring for patients with end stage disease in a supportive setting.
 
Students voiced that frequently the issues relating to dealing with the emotional aspects of caring for a patient with end stage disease had never been raised. Many were unsure of the role of the physiotherapist and anxious about dealing with these issues on clinical. They felt that this tutorial offered them the chance to not only look at the practical management of end stage patients but also to allay some of their anxieties and concerns.

Evaluation: 

This is a new tutorial in a new course / program and, as such has not yet been evaluated. It is planned to evaluate this tutorial when it is next delivered by the use of relevant discussion and student questionnaires after the session and also after their first major clinical experience. Evaluation will be aimed at determining whether students felt their experience, practice and coping skills had been increased and or enhanced by the tutorial.

Evaluation Outcomes: 

n/a

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

We are considering adding another tutorial session (or adding to the current session) on coping with death and dying in the clinical setting. It is planned to expand the content and involve other health professionals to encompass emotional issues and coping strategies relating to the death of non end stage patients.

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Rosemary Isles
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Health Sciences
Contact Institution: 
The University of Newcastle

Integration of legal and ethical issues into complex case scenarios

Developed by: 
Liisa Laakso and Norm Morris
Institution: 
Griffith University
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

Clinical Conference is a 10CP capstone course undertaken by students in the last/final semester of studies prior to the final 8 weeks of clinical placements. The course aims to fully integrate the student's prior learning in exercise science with evidence-based physiotherapy knowledge and skills using complex clinical cases. These cases are complicated by 'real-life' moral, ethical and medico-legal issues. The students study four separate cases in detail and in a holistic manner, examining the progress of patients through a continuum of care (eg, early diagnosis, acute care, sub-acute needs, rehabilitation and through to re-integration back in to the community). Sessions are led by various members of different disciplines from the healthcare team that might be involved with such cases. The cases are updated and modified each year depending on medical advances or social change.

Course Name: 
5005PES - Clinical Conference
Year Level: 
First Year
Expected Outcomes: 

Year Level : (Year 5 - final year)
 
At the end of the course the student should be able to:

  • present, discuss and justify management strategies for a variety of complex clinical case presentations with the emphasis on evidence based practice;
  • justify diagnostic decisions and management strategies on the basis of clinical assessment findings, and clinical, including propositional and non-propositional knowledge and scientific knowledge;
  • demonstrate an ability to evaluate research literature and apply results to pertinent clinical situations;
  • discuss advanced diagnostic and therapeutic concepts in physiotherapy practice;
  • identify medico-legal and ethical issues arising from clinical situations discussed.
  • Aspects of the teaching and learning practice which make it particularly effective.
  • Use of complex 'real-life' cases that incorporate specific medico-legal and ethical issues that may not have arisen in course work or clinical placements previously.
  • Use of clinical experts to lead 'in-class' discussions.
  • Incorporation of assessment items designed to lead students to identify case-specific issues and to bring together the students' entire prior learning in physiotherapy AND exercise science.

 

Effective Aspects: 

n/a

Evaluation: 

Course evaluations and individual teaching evaluations. Feedback from speakers.

Evaluation Outcomes: 

The course has been offered twice (in 2003 and 2004). The following refers to the most recent offering in 2004. Further feedback from 2003 is available on request.
2004 - Teaching evaluation
In 2004, the following questions were posed to students in evaluating each speaker in 5005PES - Clinical Conference:

  • Relevant topic content to the case study
  • Applicable content for future clinical needs
  • Good speaker would like to hear more from them in future
  • Scale: 1 = Strongly Disagree, 2 = Disagree, 3 = Undecided, 4 = Agree, 5 = Strongly Agree
  • Overall Mean for all speakers (out of total of 5) = 4.2
  • 2004 - Course Evaluation:
  • Excellent feedback has been obtained in both offerings of the course thus far, eg, in 2004:
    • "I thoroughly enjoyed this course, the chance to integrate both degrees is great and I think more of this should be done. A good mix of cases was used."
    • "Great structure to the subject; good idea with the cases and continuing process of management."
    • "Very good administration, course structured well; Good to have experts from different fields talk."
  • Sample of specific questions and responses from course evaluation (Likert scale as above, 1-5):
  • The various aspects of this course worked well together to help me to learn: Mean - 4.1
  • The level of the course was appropriate to my background. Mean - 4.2
  • This course was relevant to my vocational/professional needs. Mean - 4.2
  • The course content helped me to develop skills relevant to my professional needs. Mean 4.2
  • The overall workload in this course was reasonable. Mean - 4.1
  • In this course the convenor encouraged students to reflect about what they had learnt. Mean - 4.2
  • In this course I felt that the teachers respected me as an individual and as a learner. Mean - 4.2
  • This course helped me to further develop problem-solving skills. Mean - 4.1
  • The content of this course was clearly related to the objectives stated in the course outline. Mean - 4.0
Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

Based on 2004 student and speaker feedback for Clinical Conference, a new case will be developed in 2005 to address an identified gap in knowledge.
Based on reflections by the Course Convenor, and student feedback, the final medico-legal written assignment will be replaced by an in-class debate with specific topics related to medico-legal and ethical issues.

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Norm Morris
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Physiotherapy and Exercise Science
Contact Institution: 
Griffith University

Case studies to integrate students’ discipline knowledge and clinical reasoning skills with psychosocial, cultural and ethical perspectives

Developed by: 
Sue Jones and all academic staff
Institution: 
Curtin University of Technology
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

Case studies are used to provide a 'systems integrated' approach to the curriculum. They provide a platform for applying discipline knowledge, reinforcing principles and concepts, problem solving, clinical reasoning and critical thinking. The case studies also provide a medium for incorporating psychosocial, cultural and ethical issues and an international perspective into the undergraduate curriculum. The case studies are used to assist students with the management of patient problems with increasing levels of complexity whilst ensuring that they understand the limitations of their own skills. Whilst these case studies are horizontally integrated into the curriculum, students are also facilitated to develop skills for lifelong learning.
Whilst all streams use case studies for their teaching and learning, the Psychosocial and Professional streams have dedicated sessions that are used to consolidate and motivate student learning. These occur as tutorial sessions and master classes.
 
For the tutorial sessions, real life case studies of increasing complexity are developed and students are required to prepare relevant written work prior to class using self directed activities to guide their learning. Tutorial classes of two hours duration are used to develop students' critical thinking, problem solving and communication skills and explore the clinical reasoning associated with client problems. In the week following the class, students are required to submit a written report that requires students to reflect on their learning in the session and develop a patient evaluation, analysis, management plan and any other information required specifically for the rehabilitation of the patient.
Master classes provide an opportunity for students to observe an experienced physiotherapist assess and treat a real patient/client and discuss the clinical reasoning process used to determine the most appropriate management plan. Prior to the master class, students are encouraged to review the theory and practice related to the client's problem.
The session begins with an explanation and discussion of relevant background information, assessment and treatment of the patient/client, followed by further discussion of the assessment findings, clinical reasoning processes used in determining the results of assessment findings, development of a problem list and intervention strategies using an evidence-based approach. During this session, students participate in active discussion prior to and following the arrival of the client. These sessions allow students to participate in the critical thinking processes required in client management.

Course Name: 
Professional Practice and Psychosocial streams for all entry level programs.
Year Level: 
First Year
Expected Outcomes: 

(Year Level : The majority of units occur in the second and third years of the BSc program and the first and second year of the Master of Physiotherapy (Graduate Entry) program.)
 
See 'Teaching and learning strategy' (above)
 

Effective Aspects: 

The 'systems integrated' approach and development of critical thinking.

Evaluation: 

The School of Physiotherapy uses an online unit and course evaluation system known as Course Evaluation on the Web (CEW). This includes quantitative and qualitative feedback. This system is described in detail in an accompanying submission of an example of good teaching and learning practice in undergraduate and graduate entry Physiotherapy courses.

Evaluation Outcomes: 

Students rate their satisfaction with the case studies very highly and provide qualitative feedback about each unit of study in which case studies are used.

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

Changes occur continuously as a result of student feedback and teacher reflection from CEW.

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Sue Jones
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Physiotherapy
Contact Institution: 
Curtin University of Technology

Complex case management

Developed by: 
Bridget O'Connor and Rosemary Corrigan
Institution: 
Charles Sturt University
Teaching and Learning Strategy: 

The teaching and learning strategy revolves around the students using problem solving techniques to develop knowledge in key clinical areas. This knowledge is developed through group interaction and individual learning founded on keystone lectures that are provided at the commencement of each module. Learning issues that are developed by each group provide the evolutionary structure and timeframes for the learning process in each group to occur. The collaborative tutorial times enable the educators to provide minimal but directed input where required but in essence the learning is driven by the students

Course Name: 
Complex Case Management.
Year Level: 
Fourth Year
Expected Outcomes: 

On completion of this subject, the students will have

  • Developed skills in team work and the variables that influence effective team work
  • Developed skills in communication and interaction with diverse individuals
  • Developed insight into the impact of individual behaviours on others in a team
  • Developed knowledge in areas of
    • Spinal cord Injury
    • Indigenous health
    • Burns management
    • Aged care
  • Refugees and their assimilation in the community and health care
  • Hand (tendon) Injuries
  • Enhanced abilities to learn independently using available resources
  • Developed abilities in the sharing of knowledge relating to key areas
Effective Aspects: 
  • Linking the keystone lectures to the case based material
  • Time for students to source material independently
  • Feedback from supervisors re individual communication styles
Evaluation: 

n/a

Evaluation Outcomes: 

Extremely positive feedback from the students. Students enjoyed the team based approach and the ability to gather information and share it with others. Enjoyed the ability to be innovative in their presentations

Plans for Changes/Developments in Future: 

No significant changes are planned.
 

For Further Details
Contact Name: 
Bridget O'Connor
Contact Faculty/School: 
School of Community Health
Contact Institution: 
Charles Sturt University