Rosemary Isles, Discipline of Physiotherapy and Lieve de Clerc, Discipline of Occupational Therapy.
Institution:
The University of Newcastle
Teaching and Learning Strategy:
At the University of Newcastle, Occupational Therapy students participate in a largely Problem Based Learning program Physiotherapy students study under a program that includes foundation study of relevant scientific and behavioural disciplines and the study of specific physiotherapeutic management of conditions. In each area eg neurological, musculoskeletal, study includes many selected case-based discussions which develop clinical reasoning skills through use of true cases backed up by video resources.
Preparation for this joint tutorial session involved development of a scenario for a patient undergoing rehabilitation following stroke. Both groups of students worked with common derived learning goals that included exploration of pathology, impairments, assessment, goal setting and appropriate interventions related to the patient.
OT and PT students addressed the learning goals from their own professional perspective. Students in pairs groups developed information related to one of the learning goal areas. The lecturers ensured that all aspects of the learning goals were covered.
In the joint two hour session, 12 OT students joined with 13 PT students .They presented their topic using illustrative OHP sheets and a one page handout for five minutes and answered questions. The presentation included demonstration of assessment tools/ methods and intervention techniques where appropriate.
Discussion was facilitated by the lecturers, one from each discipline, to consider the decision making, the specific roles of the therapists and any differing philosophies of management. Students then considered how these roles might overlap and how best they could collaborate to manage this patient.
Later feedback from physiotherapy students suggested that they found that the session was valuable in gaining insight into the role and philosophy of the occupational therapist in the neurological area and further knowledge about stroke patient management.
It is planned to continue to run this tutorial and attempt to develop other joint sessions with other health professionals where appropriate. Student learning and valuing of other health professionals only occurs through first hand experience. These shared learning experiences, followed up by shared clinical experiences in later years are vital to develop co-operative graduate practice among health professionals.
Course Name:
Neurological Physiotherapy I (PHTY2030), Bachelor of Physiotherapy, University of Newcastle
Year Level:
Second Year
Expected Outcomes:
Better understanding of the roles of physiotherapists and occupational therapists in the management of stroke patients
Better understanding of differences and areas of overlap in roles and how optimal practice can be achieved
Valuing of the role of each profession in management of neurological patients
Improved clinical reasoning related to neurological patients
Identification of intervention strategies to best assist stroke patients
Effective Aspects:
The collaborative nature of the learning and ability to share and discuss disciplinary commonalities and difference
The use of a relatively small group
Evaluation:
At this stage, it was evaluated qualitatively by feedback from the group that participated. It is planned to evaluate the session this year more formally with questionnaires related to awareness of roles etc.
Evaluation Outcomes:
Physiotherapy students enjoyed the session and their learning from it.
Physiotherapy students learnt that the approach by OTs to the interventions involving neurological patients was different from their own.
They voiced appreciation of the format of instruction including case-based learning methods used in the rest of their course compared to learning in the OT course.
Plans for Changes/Developments in Future:
Minor changes
To formally evaluate its effectiveness.
The size of physiotherapy student groups will also need to be modified to accommodate a larger cohort of students (approx 25) in the shared class because of larger year group size.
In the 2nd year of the course students complete separate subjects in the core physiotherapy areas of musculoskeletal and cardiopulmonary physiotherapy. An example of the cross specialty teaching is in a practical/tutorial class scheduled towards the end of the session; classes in the two areas are combined and facilitated by teaching staff from both areas. Students are presented with two case studies and are then guided in the process of clinical reasoning about these cases. The client problems used in the case studies involve chest wall and thoracic spine pain, and thus reflect the overlap between these two areas of practice. The cardiopulmonary lecturer deliberately facilitates the case study in which the client's problems are primarily musculoskeletal in origin and the musculoskeletal lecturer facilitates reasoning in the case where the problems are primarily cardiopulmonary in origin.
The aim of the strategy is to encourage students to access and integrate knowledge from both clinical areas. The case studies are deliberately chosen to elicit students' assumptions about the different areas of physiotherapy practice. This process of shared facilitation challenges them to recognize how they may have segregated their knowledge and then challenges them to develop strategies that take a more holistic approach to patient care.
We feel that introducing this strategy at a 2nd year level influences students' learning as they develop further knowledge in core areas and prepares students for latter subjects that require more advanced integration of knowledge and reasoning, such as Complex case management.
Course Name:
Musculoskeletal and cardiopulmonary physiotherapy
Year Level:
Second Year
Expected Outcomes:
The expected learning outcomes are that students will have an increased awareness of their knowledge organization, enhanced skills in integrating knowledge from across areas of physiotherapy practice and greater ability to provide clients with holistic, patient centred care.
Effective Aspects:
A key aspect of this strategy that increases the effectiveness is having the class facilitated by teaching staff from both clinical areas. It is this aspect that challenges students to look at their assumptions.
Evaluation:
This practice has been evaluated by "Harvard 1 minute techniques" where students give blinded feedback immediately the class finishes. In addition, exam questions that call upon students to use a more holistic approach form part of the theory exam. For example, the musculoskeletal exam may contain a question regarding an orthopaedic client who has coexisting respiratory or cardiac issues.
Evaluation Outcomes:
Very promising. Students enjoy the classes, and recognise that they are pigeon-holing information that should inform their practice. The exam question responses show that, on the whole, students are approaching clinical decision making in a holistic way.
Plans for Changes/Developments in Future:
We aim to introduce cross specialty teaching between neurology and musculoskeletal.